Compositions with hydroxyalkyl piperidine or pyrrolidine oxides

ABSTRACT

COMPOSITIONS WITH HYDROXY HIGHER ALKYL PIPERIDINE OR PYRROLIDINE OXIDES PARTICULARLY WITH A SURFACE ACTIVE AGENT HAVE MANY BENEFICIAL EFFECTS IN THE DETERGENT COSMETIC FIELDS.

United States Patent Ofice 3,679,611 Patented July 25, 1972 US. Cl. 252-542 Claims ABSTRACT OF THE DISCLOSURE Compositions with hydroxy higher alkyl piperidine or pyrrolidine oxides particularly with a surface active agent have many beneficial effects in the detergent cosmetic fields.

The present application is a division of application Ser. No. 682,597 filed Nov. 13, 1967, now US. Pat. No. 3,547,932.

One aspect of this application relates to heterocyclic N-oxides of the formula where R is a long chain alkyl group of at least six carbon atoms, e.g. 6 to 20, preferably 10 to 14, carbon atoms and n is zero or one.

It has been found that the compounds of this invention have beneficial and unusual characteristics, particularly suitable, for example, in cosmetic and detergent applications.

The compounds described above may be prepared by reacting a long chain 1,2 epoxide with piperidine or pyrrolidine followed by the conversion of the resulting N-2- hydroxyalkyl piperidine or pyrrolidine to the corresponding N-oxide by oxidation, as with hydrogen peroxide.

Examples of 2-hydroxyalkyl groups are 2-hydroxydodecyl, 2-hydroxyoctadecyl, 2-hydroxynonyl, 2-hydroxydecyl, 2-hydroxyundecyl, 2-hydroxytridecyl, 2-hydroxytetradecyl, 2-hydroxypentadecyl, 2-hydroxyhexadecyl, and 2-hydroxylheptadecyl. Mixtures of compounds of different 2-hydroxyalkyl groups may be employed (e.g. a mixture in which these groups have 12-16 carbon atoms).

The compounds of this invention have many desirable attributes of particular value in emulsification and cleansing and detergency. The use of the compositions of the invention gives desirable modifications of the foaming power and/or foam characteristics of detergent compositions, such as a foam boosting effect. By using the new compounds valuable compositions intended for application to the skin or hair (or for use in contact with the skin) with good effects thereon may be formulated. This invention also provides novel compounds which may be formulated into aqueous compositions which remain stable over a satisfactory temperature range.

The novel compounds may be employed in detergent compositions, including light-duty liquids, heavy duty highly-built liquids, and granular compositions in which they may, for example, be post-added to spray-dried built detergent powders. In such detergent compositions they may be mixed with polymeric materials including agents for preventing redeposition of soil, such as sodium carboxymethylcellulose or polyvinyl alcohol; opacifiers; perfumes; anti-tarnishing agents; bacteriostatic agents; and oxygenand chlorine-releasing bleaches. The novel compounds may also be used in hair-shampooing, hair-dyeing, or other hair-treating or hair-conditioning compositions. The novel compounds may be incorporated in a variety of cosmetic compositions, including such compositions intended for application to the skin as skin lotions, creams, gels, or clear liquids.

In the use of the novel hydroxyalkyl heterocyclic N- oxides of this invention in detergent compositions, the new compound may be used alone or may be added to any of the conventional surface-active detergents. These may be of the anionic, non-ionic, cationic or amphoteric types, or mixtures thereof.

The anionic surface active agents include those surface active or detergent compounds which contain an organic hydrophobic group and an anionic solubilizing group. Typical examples of anionic solubilizing groups are sul fonate, sulfate, carboxylate, phosphonate and phosphate. Examples of suitable anionic detergents which fall within the scope of the invention include the soaps, such as the water-soluble salts of higher fatty acids or rosin acids, such as may be derived from fats, oils and waxes of animal, vegetable or marine origin, e.g. the sodium soaps of tallow, grease, coconut oil, tall oil and mixtures thereof; and the sulfated and sulfonated synthetic detergents, particularly those having about 8 to 26, and preferably about 12 to 22, carbon atoms to the molecule.

As examples of suitable synthetic anionic detergents there may be cited the higher alkyl mononuclear aromatic sulfonates such as the higher alkyl benzene sulfonates containing from 10 to 16 carbon atoms in the alkyl group in a straight or branched chain, e.g., the sodium salts of higher alkyl benzene sulfonates or of the higher alkyl toluene, xylene and phenol sulfonates; alkyl naphthalene sulfonate, ammonium diamyl naphthalene sulfonate, and sodium dinonyl naphthalene sulfonate. In one preferred type of composition there is used a linear alkyl benzene sulfonate having a high content of 3-(or higher) phenyl isomers and a correspondingly low content (well below 50%) of 2- (or lower) phenyl isomers; in other terminology, the benzene ring is preferably attached in large part at the 3 or higher (e.g. 4, 5, 6 or 7) position of the alkyl group and the content of isomers in which the benzene ring is attached at the 2 or 1 position is correspondingly low. Particularly preferred materials are set forth in US. Pat. 3,320,174, May 16, 1967, of I. Rubinfeld.

Other anionic detergents are the olefin sulfonates, including long chain alkene sulfonates, long chain hydroxyalkane sulfonates or mixtures of alkenesulfonates and hydroxyalkanesulfonates. These olefin sulfonate detergents may be prepared, in known manner, by the reaction of with long chain olefins (of 8-25, preferably 1221 carbon atoms) of the formula RCH=CHR where R is alkyl and R is alkyl or hydrogen, to produce a mixture of sultones and alkenesulfonic acids, which mixture is then treated to convert the sultones to sulfonates. Examples of other sulfate or sulfonate detergents are paraflin sulfo nates, such as the reaction products of alpha olefins and 'bisulfites (e.g. sodium bisulfite), e.g. primary paraffin sulfonates of about 10-20, preferably about 15-20, carbon atoms; sulfates of higher alcohols; salts of a-sulfofatty esters (e.g. of about 10-to 20 carbon atoms, such as methyl a-sulfomyristate or a-sulfotallowate).

Examples of sulfates of higher alcohols are sodium lauryl sulfate, sodium tallow alcohol sulfate. Turkey Red Oil or other sulfated oils, or sulfates of monoor diglycerides of fatty acids (e.g. stearic monoglyceride monosulfate), alkyl poly (ethenoxy) ether sulfates such as the sulfates of the condensation products of ethylene oxide and lauryl alcohol (usually having 1 to 5 ethenoxy groups permolecule); lauryl or other higher alkyl glyceryl ether sulfonates; aromatic poly (ethenoxy) ether sulfates such as the sulfates of the condensation products of ethylene oxide and nonyl phenol (usually having 1 to 6 oxyethylene groups per molecule).

The suitable anionic detergents include also the acyl sarcosinates (e.g. sodium lauroylsarcosinate) the acyl esters (e.g. oleic acid ester) of isethionates, and the acyl N-methyl taurides (e.g. potassium N-methyl lauroylor oleyl tauride).

The most highly preferred water soluble anionic detergent compounds are the ammonium and substituted ammonium (such as mono-, diand triethanolamine), alkali metal (such as sodium and potassium) and alkaline earth metal (such as calcium and magnesium)'salts of the higher alkyl benzene sulfonates, olefin sulfonates, the higher alkyl sulfates, and the higher fatty acid monoglyceride sulfates. The particuar salt will be suitably selected depending upon the particular formulation and the proportions therein.

glycol.

As examples of nonionic surface active agents which may be used there may be noted the condensation products of alkyl phenols with ethylene oxides, e.g., the reaction product of isooctyl phenol with about 6 to 30 ethylene oxide units; condensation products of alkyl thiophevnols with 10 to ethylene oxide units; condensation products of higher fatty alcohols such as tridecyl alcohol withethylene oxide; ethylene oxide addends of monoesters of hexahydric alcohols and inner ethers thereof such as sorbitan monolaurate, sorbitol mono-oleate and mannitan monopalmitate, and the condensation products of polypropylene glycol with ethylene oxide.

Cationic surface active agents may also be employed. Such agents are those surface active detergent compounds which contain an organic hydrophobic group and a cationic solubilizing group. Typical cations solubilizing groups are amine and quaternary groups.

As examples of suitable synthetic cationic detergents there may be noted the diamines such as those of the type RNHC ILNH wherein R is an alkyl group of about 12 to 22 carbon atoms, such as N-Z-ami'noethyl stearyl amine and N-2-aminoethyl myristyl amine; amide-linked amines such as those of the type R CONHC H NH wherein R is an alkyl group of about 9 to carbon atoms, such as N-2-amino ethylstearyl amide and N-amino ethyl myristyl amide; quaternary ammonium compounds wherein typically one of the groups linked to the nitrogen atom is an alkyl group of about 12 to 18 carbon atoms and three of the groups linked to the nitrogen atom are alkyl groups which contain 1 to 3 carbon atoms, including such 1 to 3 carbon alkyl groups bearing inert substituents, such as phenyl groups, and there is present an anion such as halogen, acetate,methosulfate, etc. Typical quaternary ammonium detergents are ethyl-dimethylstearyl ammonium chloride, benzyl-dimethyl-stearyl ammonium chloride, benzyl-dimethyl-stearyl ammonium chloride, trimethyl stearyl ammonium chloride, trimethylcetyl ammonium bromide, dimethyl-ethyl dilauryl ammonium chloride, dimethyl-propyl-myristyl ammonium chloride, and the corresponding methosulfates and acetates.

Examples of suitable amphoteric detergents are those containing both an anionic and a cationic group and a hydrophobic organic group, which is advantageously a higher aliphatic radical, e.g. of 10-20 carbon atoms. Among these are the N-long chain alkyl aminocarboxylic acids (e.g. of the formula the N-long chain alkyl iminodicarboxylic acids (e.g. of the formula RN(R'COOM) and the N-long chain alkyl betaines (e.g. of the formula v where R is a long chain alkyl group, e.g. of about 10-20 carbons, R is a divalent radical joining the amino and carboxyl portions of an amino acid (e.g. an alkylene radical of 1-4 carbon atoms), M is hydrogen or a saltforming metal, R is a hydrogen or another monovalent substituent (e.g. methyl or other lower alkyl), and R and R are monovalent substituents joined to the nitrogen by carbon-to-nitrogen bonds (e.g. methyl or other lower alkyl substituents). Examples of specific amphoteric detergents are N-alkyl-beta-aminopropionic acid; N-alkylbeta-iminodipropionic acid, and N-alkyl, N,N-dimethyl glycine; the alkyl group may be, for example, that derived from coco fatty alcohol, lauryl alcohol, myristyl alcohol (or a lauryl-myristyl mixture), hydrogenated tallow alcohol, cetyl, stearyl, or blends of such alcohols. 'Ihe substituted aminopropionic and iminodipropionic acids are often supplied in the sodium or other salt forms, which may likewise be used in the practice of this invention. Examples of other amphoteric detergents are the fatty imidazolines such as those made by reacting a long chain fatty acid (e.g. of 10 to 20 carbon atoms) with.

widely, e.g. in the range of ratios of 100:1 to 1:100;

preferably about 5 to 30 parts of the novel heterocyclic N-oxide per 100 parts of the other detergent are used.

A very suitable dishwashing liquid detergent may contain, for example, a mixture of a linear higher alkylbenzene sulfonate and a higher alkyl ether sulfate in a ratio of about 0.4:1 to 1:1 together with the heterocyclic N-oxide. In one type of sulfate-alkylbenzenesulfonate mixture highly effective for this purpose, the alkylphenyl moiety has a molecular weightof 230 to 240; its alkyl group is largely (at least mol percent) in the C10 to C12 range, at least half of the alkyls in the C10-C12, range being C10 and C11, the C10 and C11 being at least 45% of the total alkyl, at least80% of the alkyl substituent being alkyl groups having the benzene attachment on the 3- (or higher, e.g. 3-, 4-, 5-, or 6-) carbon of the alkyl. The higher alkyl ether sulfate in this dishwashing formulation may, for example, have the formula R(CH CH SO M where R is long chain alkyl of 10 to 15 carbon atoms, n is about 1 to (e.g. about 3) and M is a cation such as ammonium, sodium, potassium, monodi or triethanolammonium, etc.

Water-soluble builder salts may also be present, in the usual proportions, in the detergent formulations when heavy duty cleaning is desired. These salts include phosphates and particularly condensed phosphates (e.g. pyrophosphates or tripolyphosphates), silicates, borates and carbonates (including bicarbonates), as well as organic builders such as salts of nitrilotriacetic acid or ethylene diamine tetracetic acid. Sodium and potassium salts are preferred. Specific examples are sodium tripolyphosphate, potassium pyrophosphate, sodium hexametaphosphate, sodium carbonate, sodium bicarbonate, sodium sesquicarbonate, sodium tetraborate, sodium silicate, salts (e.g. Na salt) of methylene diphosphonic acid, trisodium nitriloacetate, or mixtures of such builders, including mixtures of pentasodium tripolyphosphate and trisodium nitrilotriacetate in a ratio, of these two builders, of 1:10 to :1, e.g. 1:1. The proportions of builder salt may be, for example, 50 parts or more (e.g. 50 to 1000 parts) per 100 parts of detergent. A granular heavy duty detergent composition for washing clothes may comprise, for example, about -18% linear tridecylbenzenesulfonate of the type disclosed in Rubinfeld US. Pat. 3,320,174, May 16, 1967, about -50% hydrated pentasodium tripolyphosphate, about 3 to 8% sodium silicate, about 25% of the novel N-Z-hydroxydodecyl heterocyclic N-oxide, and the balance sodium sulfate. A heavy duty detergent liquid composition for washing clothes in cool water may comprise, for example, an aqueous solution containing about 10% of a non-ionic detergent, about of tetrapotassium pyrophosphate, about 1-7% of the novel N-hydroxyalkyl heterocyclic N-oxide and about 4% sodium silicate. Optical brighteners and soilsuspending agents may be included in the usual minor amounts in each case.

In formulating the novel hydroxyalkyl heterocyclic N-oxides of this invention into skin lotions, the new compound may be incorporated into the well known hand lotions, containing water-immiscible materials such as minerals, blends of liquid mineral oils with high boiling petroleum fractions (such as paraffin wax, petrolatum or oxocerite), lanolin, fatty oil esters such as glyceryl monostearate, and fatty acids such as stearic or oleic acid. These water-immiscible materials may be components of an oil phase of an oil-in-water emulsion. A blend of about 13 parts of mineral oil, about 0.5-2 parts of either lanolin or lanolin alcohol or a mixture of these, about 1-3 parts of fatty acid and about 2-7 parts of polyhydroxy compound such as glyceryl monostearate may be used as the oil phase. The ratio of aqueous phase to oil phase is typically about 5:1 to 20:1. The aqueous phase may contain a detergent surfactant, for example, in concentration of about 0.1 to 5% of said phase. The amount of the novel N-hydroxyalkyl heterocyclic N-oxide in the 10- tion may be, for example, in the range of about 0.2-5%.

In a typical method for making the lotion comprising an oil-in-water emulsion, the oil phase and water phase are heated (e.g. to 70-80 C. say 74 C.) and the oil phase is added to the water phase and mixed thoroughly. The temperature is then lowered (e.g. to -50 C. say C.) and additional ingredients such as glycerine and calcium caseinate or other hydrophilic colloid are incorporated into the water phase of the emulsion.

The novel hydroxyalkyl heterocyclic N-oxides of this invention may be used in shampoo compositions in which they may be blended with any suitable water-soluble anionic detergent, which may be one of the well known types used in shampoos, e.g. an alkyl sulfate of, for example, 12-18 carbon atoms, such as sodium lauryl sulfate or sodium tallow alcohol sulfate other sulfate detergents such as the triethanolammonium salt of the monosulfate of an ethoxylated lauryl alcohol (made from, for example, 3 mols of ethylene oxide and one mol of coconut alcohol), or a sulfonate detergent, such as an alkylbenzenesulfonate or olefin sulfonate or an amphoteric detergent such as an N-long chain alkyl aminocarboxylic acid or an N-long chain alkyl iminodicarboxylic acid, as previously described herein. A typical shampoo composition may comprise, for example, an aqueous mixture containing about 1 to 15% of the novel hydroxyalkyl heterocyclic N-oxide and about 10 to 30% of the other detergent, and may be in free flowing liquid, cream, or lotion form.

The novel hydroxyalkyl heterocyclic N-oxides of this invention may also be used as constituents of toilet bars, in admixture with conventional toilet soaps, such as the usual sodium soap of a mixture of about 3 parts of tallow fatty acids and one part of coconut oil fatty acids, or in admixture with synthetic detergents such as the olefin sulfonates mentioned above or the long chain fatty acid (e.g. coconut oil fatty acid) monoglyceryl sulfates. In one example, about 15 parts of the novel hydroxyalkyl heterocyclic amine oxide is used with parts of the other detergent (soap or synthetic).

The following examples are given to illustrate this invention further. In these examples, as in the remainder of the application, all proportions are by weight unless otherwise indicated.

Example 1 20 grams of 1,2 epoxydodecane (B.P. 97-98 C. at 3.5 mm. Hg A) is heated with 10 grams of piperidine at 100 C. in a sealed container overnight. The resulting mixture is then fractionally distilled under vacuum; the fraction obtained at a head temperature of C. and a pressure of 0.05 mm. Hg A, is a clear, oily liquid, N-2- hydroxydodecyl piperidine. To 22.9 grams of this product, dissolved in 40 cc. of a 1:1 mixture of methanol and water, there are added, dropwise, 9.6 grams of aqueous 30% hydrogen peroxide and the mixture is heated at 60 C. for 1 hour. Thereafter any excess peroxide is decomposed by adding 0.1 gram platinum black-on-charcoal (of 5% Pt content) and maintaining the mixture for 3 hours, after which the platinum-on-charcoal catalyst is filtered off, and the filtrate is evaporated to recover the crude product, which is then recrystallized from cc. of acetone to produce 11.7 grams of purified N-2-hydroxydodecylpiperidine N-oxide which melts an decomposes at 143-151 C.

Example 2 A mixture of Cl2-C16 alpha olefins is epoxidized in conventional manner to give a mixture of 1,2-epoxyalkanes of 12-16 carbon atoms having an average molecular weight of about 207. This is substituted mol-for-mol for the epoxydodecane used in Example 1.

Example 3 Pyrrolidine is substituted mol-for-mol for the piperidine used in Example 1, to produce N-Z-hydroxydodecylpyrrolidine.

Example 4 A satisfactory detergent composition having suitable overall detergency and foaming characteristics contains 0.8 g. of the hydroxyalkyl heterocyclic amine oxide of Example 1, 3.3 g. sodium linear tridecylbenzenesulfonate and 6.7 g. anhydrous pentasodium tripolyphosphate.

Example 5 A hand lotion is formulated from the following ingredients:

(a) An aqueous mixture of 74.4 parts deionized water, 1 part sodium lauryl sulfate, 1 part of the hydroxyalkyl heterocyclic amine oxide of Example 1, and, as preservatives, 0.18 part methyl p-hydroxybenzoate and 0.22 part propyl p-hydroxybenzoate.

" V perfume.

The oily mixture (b) is melted and added to the aqueous mixture (a) while the latter is in heated agitated condition, to form an emulsion, which is allowed to cool. To the resulting warm mixture the glycerine-caseinatewater blend is added, with stirring, and after further cooling, to room temperature, the benzyl-alcohol-perfume mixture (d) is added. The presence of the benzylalcohol helps to control the viscosity of the lotion.

Example 6 Liquid aqueous compositions of satisfactory detergent and foaming power are formulated as follows:

of an alkylbenzene of molecular weight 238, containing mainly alkyl groups of 10 to 12 carbons.

(b) Example 6(a) is repeated except that the fatty acid monoethanolamide is omitted from the composition. (c) A liquid detergent composition is formulated from: the alkylbenzenesulfonate of'Example 6(a), 35%; the ammonium alkyl ether sulfate of Example 6(a), 4%; N-Z-hydroxydodecyl-piperidine oxide, 5%; ethanol, 5.1% urea, 5%; sodium xylene sulfonate, 1.7%, and water.

(d) Another liquid detergent composition contains 23 of the sodium linear alkylbenzenesulfonate of Example 6(a), 13% of the ammonium salt of sulfated ethoxylated 'alkanol of Example 7; 5% of the N-Z-hydroxydodecyl piperidine oxide 5% of sodium xylene sulfonate (hydrotrope), and water. The mixture is adjusted to a pH of 7.5. (e) A liquid detergent for use in the machine-washing of clothes in cool water is prepared by mixing in the following order, at a temperature of l45-l80 F. 32.3 parts of water; 0.005 part of a non-ionic detergent which is a polyoxyethylated nonyl phenol (specifically a condensation product of 15 mols of ethylene oxide and 1 mol of nonyl phenol); and 1 part of a copolymer of vinylmethyl ether and maleic anhydride (Gantrez AN-908); under these conditions the anhydride ring of the copolymer opens, forming an acidic partial ester with the polyethoxylated nonyl phenol. There are then added 1.6 parts of an aqueous 45.4% solution of KOH; 0.69 part of sodium carboxymethylcellulo'se; 2 parts of a aqueous dispersion of fluorescent brighteners; 1.7 parts of an aqueous 1% solution of blue dye (Polar Brilliant Blue); 0.12 part of an aqueous 0.5% solution of green dye (D & C Green #8); 8.56 part of aqueous sodium silicate of 43.5% concentration in which the Na O; Si0 mol ratio is 122.35); 10 parts of a non-ionic detergent which is a poly oxyethylated alkyl phenol (specifically -a condensation product of 10 mols of ethylene oxide and one mol of branched chain dodecyl phenol); 1 to 5 parts of N-hy- Example 7 r (a) A shampoo composition is prepared by mixing 2 v to 5% N-Z-hydroxydodecyl-Piperidine oxide, 10% tri ethanolammonium lauryl sulfate, and the balance, water.

(b) In another shampoo composition there is used 10% of sodium monosulfate of ethoxylated lauryl alcohol (made with 3 to 4 mols of ethylene oxide per mol of lauryl alcohol) in place of the triethanolammoniumlauryl sulfate of Example 7(a).

(c) Another shampoo composition contains 10% o triethanolamine oleate, 9% of N-Z-hydroxydodecyl-piper- .idine oxide, and 1.6% of a cationic dispersing agent, oleyl dimethyl benzyl ammonium chloride and, the balance,

water.

(d) A shampoo composition, in gel form, contains 68% of an aqueous 41% solution of triethanolammonium lauryl sulfate; 6% sorbitol; 4% ethyl alcohol; 1.8% methyl cellulose, serving as a thickener; 5% lauric-inyristic diethanolamide; 1% N Z-hydroxydodecyl-piperidine oxide; a small amount of formaldehyde as a preservative and the balance water. The pH is adjusted to 7.2, as by addition of triethanolamine.

While the invention finds its greatest utility in the embodiment in which the unsubstituted 2 hydroxyalkyl heterocyclic amine oxides are used, it is also within the broader scope of this invention to use long chain. 3-hydroxyalkyl heterocyclic amine oxides (which may be made in the same way as the corresponding Z-hydroxyalkyl compounds, using the corresponding 1,3 oxetane in place of the 1,2 epoxide) and to use those hydroxyalkyl piperidine or pyrrolidine oxides which have a substituent such as lower alkyl (e.g. methyl, ethyl or propyl) on one or more of the carbon atoms of the heterocyclic ring, form'- ing such compounds as N-(3-hydroxydodecyl) piperidine oxide or N-(Z-hydroxyhexadeCyl) 2 methylpyrrolidine oxide.

It is to be understood that the foregoing detailed de-" where R is a long chain alkyl group of six to twenty carbon atoms and n is zero or one; and heterocyclic oxides of said formula wherein the heterocyclic ring contains lower alkyl substituents.

2. A composition in accordance with claim 1 wherein the heterocyclic oxide is N-2-hydroxydodecyl piperidine N-oxide and the ratio of detergent to heterocyclic oxide is about :1 to 1:100 by weight.

3. A composition in accordance with claim 1 wherein the heterocyclic oxide is N-Z-hydroxydodecyl piperidine N-oxide and the ratio of detergent to heterocyclic oxide is about 100:1 to 1:100 by weight. 0

4. A hand-lotion composition in accordance withclaim 1 additionally containing a water-immiscible oily material selected from the group consisting of mineral oils, lanolin, fatty oil esters, and fatty acids.

5. A hand lotion in accordance with claim 4 containing mineral oil as the oily material.

6. A hand lotion in accordance with claim 5 in which the mineral oil is dispersed in'water containing said heterocyclic oxide dissolved therein.

7. A foaming detergent composition in accordance with References Cited claim 1 wherein at least a part of the detergent is an UNITED STATES PATENTS anionic sulfonate or sulfate detergent.

8. A composition in accordance with claim 7 wherein 2,731,421 1/1956 Stayner 252-"137 at least a part of the detergent is a linear alkylbenzene- 5 2353526 9/1960 Bergman et a1 252 8-8 sulfonate having 10 to 16 carbon atoms in the alkyl. 3,474,038 10/1969 SaPulreda: et a1 9. A composition in accordance with claim 7 in which 3,547,932 12/1970 Gerecht 252-137 XR ghgoggiomc detergent 1s a sulfate of a higher allphatrc LEON D. ROSDOL Primary Examiner 10. A composition in accordancewith claim 7 addi- 10 D. SILVERSTEIN, Assistant Examiner tionally containing a builder salt in which the proportion of builder salt is 50 to 1000 parts per 100 parts of organic US. Cl. X.R. detergent in said composition. 252524, 528, 547 

